2020 Resident Debates
1st Place - Karl Godlewski, MD - University of Pennsylvania
2nd - MJ Counsilman, MD - Thomas Jefferson University Hospital
3rd - Sarah Christianson, DO - Einstein Healthcare
4th - Linda Hsu, MD - Temple University Hospital
2019 Resident Debates
1st place-Eric Ghiraldi, DO (Einstein)
2nd- Jeffrey Walker, MD (Penn State-Hershey)
3rd- Shaun Hager, DO (Main Line Health)
2018 Resident Debates
1st Place – Marshall Strother, MD (Penn)
2nd Place – Andrew Pridjian, MD (Jefferson)
3rd Place – Daniel Edwards, DO (Hahnemann)
2017 Resident Debates
Overall Winner: Dr. Matthew Brennan (Einstein)
Attending Debates
2014 (8th Annual)
Host: David McGinnis, MD (Academic Urology)
First Debate:
Jeanne Hoffman-Censits (Jefferson) vs. David Vaughn (Penn)
- Neoadjuvant Chemotherapy Versus Risk Stratification/ Adjuvant Chemotherapy for Urothelial Carcinoma
Second Debate:
Bradley Figler (Jefferson) vs.Jay Simhan (Einstein/Fox Chase)
- Early Realignment Versus Delayed Repair of Posterior Urethral Disruption
2012 (6th Annual)
First Debate:
Leonard Gomella (Jefferson) vs. Jessica Herzstein (Penn)
- PSA: to Screen or Not to Screen, That is the Question
Second Debate:
Tia Schellato (Urologic Consultants) vs. Ariana Smith (Penn)
- The Utility of Urodynamics Evaluation Before SUI Surgery
2011 (5th Annual)
First Debate:
Brett Lebed (Urologic Associates) vs. David Sussman (Delaware Valley Urology)
- Management of Refractory OAB
Second Debate:
Alexander Kutikov (Fox Chase) vs. Thomas Guzzo (Penn)
- Management of High Risk NSGCT
2010 (4th Annual)
Host: Edouard Trabulsi, MD (Jefferson)
First Debate: Eric Horowitz (Fox Chase) vs. Justin Bekelman (Penn)
Prostate Cancer Radiation Treatment - IMRT vs. Proton Beam
Second Debate:
Steven Hirshberg (UHS-Abington) vs. Allen Seftel (Cooper)
Management of Post-Vasectomy Reversal vs. IVF/ICSI
Third Debate:
Richard Greenberg (Fox Chase) vs. Gordon Brown (UMDNJ-Kennedy)
Management of BCG-Refractory High Grade Bladder Cancer: Salvage Intravesical Treatment vs. Early Cystectomy
2009 (3rd Annual)
Host: Leo Doumanian, MD (Temple)
First Debate:
Scott Hubosky (Jefferson) vs. Lia Viterbo (Fox Chase)
- Upper Tract Urothelial Cancer: Endoscopic Management vs. Robotic Nephroureterectomy
Second Debate: Pat Casale (Children's Hospital of Philadelphia) vs. Mark Zaontz (Temple)
- Management of Vesicoureteral Reflux: Robotic Reimplantation vs. Endoscopic Injection Therapy
2008 (2nd Annual)
Host: Patrick Shenot, MD (Jefferson)
First Debate:
William Jaffe (Penn) vs. Michael Metro (Einstein)
- Management of Male Incontinence: AUS vs. Male Sling
Second Debate:
Michael Pontari (Temple) vs. Kristene Whitmore (Graduate)
- Interstitial Cystitis: Localized Bladder Disease vs. A Systemic Disorder
Third Debate:
Richard Harkaway (Einstein) vs. Jim Squadrito (Academic Urology)
- BPH Management: Optimized Medicine vs. Minimally Invasive Therapy
2007 (Inaugural)
Host: Michael Metro, MD (Einstein)
First Debate:
Bruce Malkowicz (Penn) vs. Edouard Trabulsi (Jefferson)
- Indications for Prostate Biopsy 2007
Second Debate:
Ilia Zeltser (Academic Urology) vs. Robert Uzzo (Fox Chase)
- Management of the Small Renal Mass in Elderly Patients